METHODOLOGY FOR EVALUATION AND SELECTION OF PLM-SYSTEMS IN THE DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION OF A MACHINE-BUILDING ENTERPRISE
Abstract
As part of the transition to the sixth technological order, the question of effective implementation
of the digital transformation of the enterprise is acute for industrial enterprises. To do this, enterprises
need to ensure the transition to process management, automate business processes and integrate all
processes, applications and data on a single platform. There is a problem of choosing a way to combine
information flows between various software tools in the enterprise, one of the solutions is the use of a
PLM system. With a discrete type of production, their use is difficult due to the large number of softwaresolutions in the main, organizational, supporting and business development processes. In this regard, it
is necessary to determine the optimal system that would meet all the necessary criteria for building a
single platform for a "seamless" production process. There are a large number of PLM systems on the
market that implement a certain number of functional appointments. The choice of a PLM system should
be based on the satisfaction of an interconnected set of enterprise requirements, which are determined
based on business processes. This will eliminate most unsuitable software solutions. At the same time, a
PLM system that has the widest functionality may not meet the requirements for creating a system for
ensuring integration with business process automation systems, as well as economic, social, political
and other requirements. Therefore, an individual list of criteria is compiled for each enterprise in accordance
with the field of activity, the type of production, the availability of various software, the existing
level of automation and other parameters. The article proposes a methodology for choosing PLM
systems for a radio-electronic engineering enterprise, based on the analysis of business processes and
determining the requirements of the enterprise, monitoring and determining the functional purposes of
PLM systems and determining the optimal option based on the hierarchy analysis method. Obtaining an
integrated assessment of certain criteria and software solutions options will allow an objective choice of
the optimal PLM system for a particular enterprise. The use of the methodology will speed up and improve
the quality of the PLM system selection process for a certain enterprise in the conditions of transition
to the sixth technological order and industry 4.0.
References
transformation. How to survive and succeed in the new era]. Moskow: Izd-vo «MIF», 2020.
2. Eraskin N.G., Ivanova M.A., Saltykova N.V. Vnedrenie kontseptsii PLM na predpriyatii [Introduction
of the PLM concept at the enterprise], Molodoy uchenyy [Young scientist], 2021,
No. 2, pp. 14-17.
3. Voronin P.A., Belevtsev A.M., Epaneshnikova I.K., Sadreev F.G. Razrabotka obshchikh
protsedur integratsii informatsionnogo vzaimodeystviya plm-sistem i low-code platformkonstruktorov
[Development of common procedures for the integration of information interaction
between PLM systems and low-code design platforms], Vserossiyskaya nauchnoprakticheskaya
konferentsiya molodykh spetsialistov «Sistemy upravleniya polnym zhiznennym
tsiklom vysokotekhnologichnoy produktsii v mashinostroenii: novye istochniki rosta» [All-
Russian Scientific and Practical conference of young specialists "Management systems for the
full life cycle of high-tech products in mechanical engineering: new sources of growth"], 2021,
4. Butusov N.O., Buza M.N., Alekhin A.G. Razrabotka avtomatizirovannoy sistemy upravleniya
proizvodstvom diskretnogo tipa [Development of an automated production management system
of discrete type], Izvestiya Volgogradskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta
[Izvestiya Volgograd State Technical University], 2022.
5. Kapustina A.I. Integratsiya sistem programmnogo i matematicheskogo obespecheniya dlya
modelirovaniya i issledovaniya avtomatizirovannykh sistem upravleniya [Integration of software
and mathematical support systems for modeling and research of automated control systems],
ENERGIYA-2021: SHestnadtsataya vserossiyskaya (vos'maya mezhdunarodnaya)
nauchno-tekhnicheskaya konferentsiya studentov, aspirantov i molodykh uchenykh
[ENERGIA-2021: The sixteenth All-Russian (eighth International) Scientific and Technical
Conference of students, postgraduates and young scientists]. In 6 vol. Ivanovo, 2021.
6. Yakubova V.A. Issledovanie protsessov vzaimodeystviya s potrebitelyami v ramkakh CRMsistemy
predpriyatiya po proizvodstvu i realizatsii mebel'nykh izdeliy [Research of the processes
of interaction with consumers within the CRM system of the enterprise for the production
and sale of furniture products], Studencheskiy vestnik [Student Bulletin], 2022.
7. Ifanov A.V., Poltavtsev A.A. Tekhnologii workflow v sozdanii raspredelennykh sistem
obrabotki zakazov [Workflow technologies in the creation of distributed order processing systems],
Problemy informatiki v obrazovanii, upravlenii, ekonomike i tekhnike: Sb. statey XXI
Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-tekhnicheskoy konferentsii [Problems of informatics in education,
management, economics and technology: Collection of articles of the XXI International Scientific
and Technical Conference]. Penza: Penzenskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet, 2021.
8. Kulachenko I.A. Sistemy informatsionnoy zashchity pri peredache dannykh [Information security
systems for data transmission]. Nauchno-issledovatel'skiy tsentr "Vektor razvitiya", 2022.
9. Vlasenko A.N., Aleksandrova S.S., Sadreev F.G., Voronin P.A. Avtomatizatsiya sozdaniya
inzhenernykh uchebnykh webgl prilozheniy [Automating the creation of engineering educational
webgl applications], Tr. Mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii po komp'yuternoy grafiki i
zreniyu "Grafikon"» [Proceedings of the International Conference on Computer Graphics and
Vision "Graphicon"], 2021.
10. Loginov I.V. Diagnostirovanie funktsional'noy prigodnosti razvivayushchikhsya mnogofunktsional'nykh
avtomatizirovannykh sistem na osnove perestraivaemoy modeli [Diagnosing
the functional suitability of developing multi-functional automated systems based on a tunable
model], Programmnye produkty i sistemy [Software products and systems], 2022, Vol. 35,
No. 2, pp. 195-207.
11. Sinitsyna E.V., Gusev A.A. Problema importozameshcheniya v sfere mikroelektroniki i
sozdaniya rossiyskogo apparatnogo obespecheniya [The problem of import substitution in the
field of microelectronics and the creation of Russian hardware], Vestnik Instituta mirovykh
tsivilizatsiy [Bulletin of the Institute of World Civilizations], 2022.
12. Khan V.L. Soprovozhdenie sistem avtomatizatsii programmnogo obespecheniya [Maintenance
of software automation systems], Perspektivy razvitiya informatsionnykh tekhnologiy [Prospects
for the development of information technologies], 2011, No. 3-2, pp. 152-156.
13. LOTSMAN: PLM – Askon [PILOT: PLM – Askon]. Available at: https://ascon.ru/.
14. T-Flex PLM – «TOP Sistemy» [T-Flex PLM – "TOP Systems"]. Available at:
https://www.tflex.ru/plm/.
15. Soyuz-PLM – Programsoyuz [Union-PLM – Program Union]. Available at:
http://www.programsoyuz.ru/products/system-soyuz-plm/.
16. IPS – Intermekh [IPS – Intermech]. Available at: https://intermech.ru/ips_product.html.
17. KSED – KROK [CSED – CROC]. Available at: https://www.croc.ru/businesssolutions/
content-management-and-workflow/.
18. Appius – GK Appius [Appius – GC Appius]. Available at: https://www.appius.ru/.
19. Sistema polnogo zhiznennogo tsikla [A full life cycle system]. Available at:
https://nnov.hse.ru/mirror/pubs/share/226534016.
20. Sistema «Tsifrovoe predpriyatie» [The Digital Enterprise system]. Available at:
https://tsifrovoepredpriyatie.rf.
21. Balyberdin V.A., Belevtsev A.M., Benderskiy G.P. Prikladnye metody otsenki i vybora resheniy
v strategicheskikh zadachakh innovatsionnogo menedzhmenta [Applied methods of evaluation
and choice of solutions in strategic tasks of innovation management]. Moscow: Dashkov i K,
2014, 240 p.
