MODEL OF SELF-OSCILLATING CIRCUIT FOR TESTING NUMERICAL METHODS OF TRANSIENT ANALYSIS IN SPICE-SIMULATORS
Abstract
At present time the problem of developing methods for numerical analysis of RF circuits in the
time domain remains actual because the known Gear and trapezoidal methods used in SPICE simulators
have a number of significant disadvantages. To evaluate the effectiveness of new numerical methods,
special test problems are needed to determine the accuracy of methods in various operating modes.
Numerical analysis of self-oscillating circuits in the time domain offers the most difficulties for circuit
simulation programs (SPICE-simulators) since models of self-oscillating circuits can be both oscillatory
and stiff simultaneously. The aim of this work is to create the model of a self-oscillating circuit that allows
to quantify the accuracy of numerical methods. In accordance with the aim, the following problems
are solved: the features of the numerical analysis of classical self-oscillators in SPICE-simulators are
investigated; the generalized mathematical model of self-oscillating circuits is described; the universal
circuit model of self-oscillating circuits for SPICE-simulators is presented; the quantitative accuracy
assessment of numerical methods of transient analysis in SPICE-simulators was carried out. The model
proposed in this paper makes it possible to determine the relative errors of numerical methods in the
harmonic oscillations mode, in the relaxation oscillations mode, as well as in the «mixed» mode, when
the circuit response contains both exponential components with different rates of change and quasiharmonic
components. The obtained results confirm the high accuracy of the trapezoidal method in the
mode of harmonic oscillations, and the Gear method in the mode of relaxation oscillations. The relative
errors in determining the amplitude of oscillation using these methods for the corresponding operating
modes do not exceed 3%. At the same time, in the «mixed» mode, the relative errors in determining the
amplitude of oscillation for both methods can reach 100%, that confirms the need to use additional
options or special methods of numerical analysis in SPICE-simulators.
References
dlya programm modelirovaniya dinamiki tekhnicheskikh sistem [Problems of developing a
mathematical core for modeling the dynamics of technical systems], Problemy razrabotki
perspektivnykh mikro- i nanoelektronnykh sistem [Problems of Perspective Micro- and
Nanoelectronic Systems Development], 2020, No 4, pp. 31-38.
2. Bernardini A., Maffezzoni P., Sarti A. Linear Multistep Discretization Methods with Variable
Step-Size in Nonlinear Wave Digital Structures for Virtual Analog Modeling, IEEE/ACM Transactions
on Audio, Speech, and Language Processing, 2019, Vol. 27, No. 11, pp. 1763-1776.
3. Pilipenko A.M., Biryukov V.N. Development and Testing of High Accuracy Hybrid Methods
for Time-Domain Simulation of Electronic Circuits and Systems, Proceedings of 2017 IEEE
East-West Design and Test Symposium (EWDTS), 2017. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1109/
EWDTS.2017.8110124.
4. Maffezzoni P., Codecasa L., D’Amore D. Time-domain simulation of nonlinear circuits
through implicit Runge–Kutta methods, IEEE Transactions on Circuits Systems – I: Regular
Papers, 2007, Vol. 54, No. 2, pp. 391-400.
5. Hairer E. Wanner G. Solving Ordinary Differential Equations II: Stiff and Differential-
Algebraic Problems. 2nd rev. ed., Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1996, 614 p.
6. Ascher U.M. Computer Methods for Ordinary Equations and Differential-Algebraic Equations,
Philadelphia, PA: SIAM, 1998, 332 p.
7. Butcher J.C. Numerical methods for ordinary differential equations. 2nd ed., John Wiley &
Sons, 2008, 463 p.
8. Guzhev D.S., Kalitkin N.N. Uravnenie Biurgersa – test dlia chislennykh metodov [Burgers
equation is a test for numerical methods], Matematicheskoe modelirovanie [Russian Journal of
Mathematical Modeling], 1995, Vol. 7, No. 4, pp. 99-127.
9. Pilipenko A.M., Biryukov V.N. Investigation of modern numerical analysis methods of selfoscillatory
circuits efficiency, Zhurnal radioelektroniki [Journal of radio electronics], 2013,
No. 8. Available at: http://jre.cplire.ru/jre/aug13/9/text-engl.html.
10. Gonorovsky I.S. Radiotekhnicheskie tcepi i signaly: ucheb. posobie dlya stud. vuzov [Radio
engineering circuits and signals: textbook manual for university students], 5th ed., rev., Moscow:
Drofa, 2006, 717 p.
11. Manaev E.I. Osnovy radioelektroniki [Fundamentals of radio electronics], Moscow: Radio i
sviaz, 1990, 512 p.
12. NI Circuit Design Suite. Getting Started with NI Circuit Design Suite, National Instruments
Corporation, August 2010, 198 p.
13. Biriukov V.N. Rukovodstvo k laboratornym rabotam po kursu «Osnovy avtomatizirovannogo
analiza tcepei» [Guide to laboratory works on the course «Fundamentals of computer-aided
circuit analysis»], Issue 3, Taganrog: Izd-vo TRTU, 2001, 27 p.
14. Kuznetsov A.P., Kuznetsov S.P., Ryskin N.M. Nelineinye kolebaniya: ucheb. posobie dlia
vuzov [Nonlinear vibrations: textbook manual for universities], Moscow: Izd-vo fizikomatematicheskoy
literatury, 2002, 292 p.
15. Hairer E., Norsett S.P., Wanner G. Solving Ordinary Differential Equations I. Nonstiff Problems,
2nd rev. ed., Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1993, 528 p.
16. Pilipenko A.M. Biryukov V.N., Fadeeva A.B. Methods of Testing Time-Domain Simulators in
EDA Packages, Proceedings of 2016 IEEE East-West Design and Test Symposium (EWDTS),
2016, pp. 172-175.
17. Modern Numerical Methods for Ordinary Differential Equations, ed. by G. Hall, J.M. Watt,
Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1976, 336 p.
18. Maffezzoni P.A. Versatile Time-Domain Approach to Simulate Oscillators in RF Circuits,
IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems – I: Regular Papers, 2009, Vol. 56, No. 3,
pp. 594-603.
19. Biryukov V.N., Pilipenko A.M. Analiz pogreshnosti chislennogo modelirovaniya
avtogeneratorov vo vremennoy oblasti [Analysis of the error of oscillator's numerical simulation
in the time domain], Izvestiya YuFU. Tekhnicheskie nauki [Izvestiya SFedU. Engineering
Sciences], 2014, No. 11 (160), pp. 119-127.
20. Biryukov V.N., Pilipenko A.M. An Approach to Estimate the Error of Oscillator Time-
Domain Analysis, Proceedings of IEEE East-West Design and Test Symposium (EWDTS),
2013, pp. 223-226.
